If you suspect your client is guilty, what should you do?

• A. Immediately persuade the client to plead guilty regardless of evidence
• B. Withdraw from representation immediately
• C. Bring matters to the client's attention and invite them to consider a guilty plea, when appropriate
• D. Publicly challenge the client's innocence in court

Answer: (C)

When you suspect guilt, the duty is to provide candid, client-centered advice and help the client understand their options, including the possibility of a guilty plea if appropriate. You should bring the matter to the client’s attention and invite them to consider a guilty plea after discussing the evidence, the likelihood of conviction, potential sentences, and any available plea negotiations or mitigation. This approach respects the client’s autonomy, supports informed decision-making, and aligns with acting in the client’s best interests while avoiding coercion or misrepresentation.

Coercing a plea regardless of evidence is unethical, and withdrawing immediately without considering the circumstances could leave the client unsupported. Publicly challenging the client’s innocence in court is not the role of a defence lawyer and would undermine the attorney–client relationship and confidentiality.